Always Across the World: Social Media Monitering Report
Is there such a thing as a perfect company? One which does not overcharge, treats workers well, and has never had a single controversy? I mean, many would like us to think that is the case. I think Disney's entire marketing mission is to convince us that in their world nothing has ever or will ever be bad in any way. Which is just not the way to go if they want consumers to get behind them again. But enough about the so called "happiest place on earth". Despite the many deep dives I can go into on the history of Disney backlash, and believe me I have some thoughts, I bring this up only as an example of how some companies try and fail to handle negative groundswell in their favor.
Now here’s the thing about the groundswell. It is not always positive. In fact, it is often the result of someone bad as something good. For companies to maintain their social reputation, it is important for them to listen and flow not just with the positive but with the negative as well. Last time we looked at where Always has succeeded in their marketing campaigns now let’s take a look at the other end of the spectrum. If you look deep enough with any company there’s going to be something which is a little shady. Some are right on the surface, and some require a little digging
In 2019 Kenyan activist Scheaffer Okorewrote about her and many other Kenyan women’s experience using always brandproducts. Okore wrote that Kenyan women often experience rashes, inflammation, and itching whenever they use always brand pads. However, this was not the case when they bought pads from the U.S. and the U.K., leading to an investigation into the manufacture, the Always parent company P&G released a statement admitting that a plastic film top sheet made of modifier polyethene (PE) is a part of their pad construction and, due to the higher temperatures in Kenya, the PE in the pads became the cause of rashes, inflammation, and itching for women who used the products.
This story let to #MyAlwaysExperience going viral, with many Kenyan women continuing to share their story. Now here’s where we come to employ the sausage principle. For those who don’t know, the sausage principle says, “If you like something, don’t find out how it was made”. If you like the always brand, maybe skip this next part. According to Okore and various other reports, the one of the first responses to the controversy was anew twitter campaign ad featuring a black model with the hashtag#FeelTheComfortAlways. From several deep dive internet searches, it appears there is no evidence remaining evidence of this campaign leading us to think Always has attempted to erase it from their brand history. And that makes sense since this was a very poor response. This is a case of trying to ignore the groundswell and save face, but it very quickly had the opposite effect. After this PR disaster, the Always Kenya team began to host meeting with Kenyan consumers for a better understanding of needs. The #FeelTheComfortAlways was quickly replaced with #GenerationOfChange accompanies by a YouTube ad. This campaign focused on the women who spoke up and help the brand responsible. This launched with the announcement of new Always products designed for additional comfort as well as a refined PE formula to avoid previous issues.
This is a very clear growing of a company’s social maturity. I’m not sure if the same person came up with the comfort and the change campaigns or if a new team was brought t but it is a stark comparison between a campaign which understands how to flow with the groundswell and a campaign which is lagging far behind. While ignoring controversy has worked well in the past where the internet was not the force it is today, knowing how to accept criticism in essential for any consumer company.
Today the groundswell is full of individuals who, when a mistake is made, want genuine acknowledgment of remorse and active work to make amends. The #FeelTheComfortAlways campaign was an attempt to ignore the backlash which only led to more backlash. While the #GenerationOfChange campaign did was acknowledge the mistakes and celebrate to individuals who did the original calling out of the company. This is the type of acknowledgement consumers want to see and it showed the brand, at least after they had seen the backlash were willing to listen to the groundswell. Although not to the extent many Kenyan consumers wanted to see.
In the #GenerationOfChange YouTube ad there is not a direct reference to the actual complaints. Even when the so called complaints are shown they are blurred out and unreadable.
This is a strategy Always used to shake a little more negative press off their backs as an outsider watching this would only see the positive and none of the negative. So if someone unaware of the controversy comes across this video they will just think Always is improving and that's good, they will not have the context for why improving was needed. However, this is very expected from international brands. Their prerogative is to minimize the negative backlash and generating positive groundswell for the future. In this case, the brand continued to promote their most successful messaging with uplifting women and young girls. The ad launching the 'feather soft' products featured a young girl in school dancing and singing about 'being it all' and 'doing it all' while gathering her friends to go for a run.This entire controversy has seemed to push Always to increase their social media marketing in African countries as before the Generation of Change only one ad had been uploaded in 2016 while since several ads are uploaded per year with increasing amounts of views.
This whole controversy does seem to have resulted in a revamp of the Always social media marketing particularly in Africa and is a reminder to companies to not forget about markets outside the western world. Groundswell is not limited to one country, it exists world wide and needs to be listened to for the best possible marketing results.
Strengths - Always gained major ground in positive groundswell through their #LikeaGirl campaign and there educational and empowering messaging for women and girls has resulted in increased online activity. It also did eventually admit to wrongdoing and attempt to work with consumers to fix the problems with the product. This listening to the groundswell led to an increase in online activity focusing on the African market which has led to more international engagement
Weakness - Always did not take full responsibility for their wrong doings and, even when admitting to mistakes, tried to downplay the severity of those mistakes. This has resulted in even the consumers they have met with not endorsing the brand until they do more to make things right with the community.
The Solution - Always should partner directly with the women who called them out in the first place. Although Okore continues to speak out against the company, a partnership could be possible if standards where brought up to appropriate expectations and with her endorsement it would reinstall trust among the women who follow her on social media.











Hey Maeve,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your post and found it to be very informational. One of the aspects that although did not shock me but rather intrigued me was the brands desire to erase the campaign and their mistakes in a way. I find that brands often try to carper sweep their mistakes as a means of moving past them. The reality is that in order to keep the trust of your customers, being able to say, "we made a mistake, we will fix it" is perhaps the simplest and best way to battle such mistakes.
I had no idea that happened in Kenya! I always think about menstrual care around the world and how different it can be. I think you did a great job at critiquing the Always brand and I think it's important to keep investigating the best options in menstrual care. What we thought to be the best product 10 years ago might have changed since then.
ReplyDelete