A Quick Bite of Social Maturity
Have you heard of CNN+? It was the streaming service CNN launched on March 29, 2022. It featured 24/7 news coverage and a variety of different series and documentaries. Now I’m guessing you have not heard of it since it took only 30 days to be dissolved by the parent company Warner Bros. Discovery. Now why did CNN+ fail in the hardest way possible. A variety of reasons but many of those reasons have to do with the companies, or at least the part of the company that thought this was a good idea, social maturity.
Chapter 13 of Groundswell discuss the levels of social maturity companies can reach. The different levels of social maturity companies fall into are demonstrated in this table which also represents the idea of a groundswell. The majority of companies, about two-thirds, reside in the early and late majority. These companies do not start trends but also do not end them. The last third of companies are divided between the innovators and the laggards. As the name suggests, innovators are the companies which adapt to the groundswell first and innovate with popular trends, while laggards just on to the groundswell after the excitement has almost completely died down and not much is gained from joining the trend.
Now, CNN+ is a great example of a company failing the social maturity test but let’s bring in two other examples for no other reason than I want too. Let’s take a look at two different companies which took a stab in the world of mobile apps. One that succeeded, and one which very much did not.
Let’s start with the positive and look at an app which was a innovation for an already established brand and a step into the future of gaming using augmented reality. This app is Pokémon go. I’m sure all of you have played of at least have heard of this game. Pokémon go was released in July 2016 to enormous success. The game uses augmented reality to transport the world of Pokémon into the players real world. Once a player created their avatar, the games GPS would create an in-game map based on their geographical location. From here the player could travel to catch different Pokémon in their vicinity. Once a Pokémon has been found, the game uses the camera on the players mobile device to display a live image of a Pokémon in the real world. While by far not the first augmented reality game, Pokémon Go was a landmark in bring augmented reality into the mainstream.
The groundswell response was immediate and strong, with the app becoming the fastest to top the app store and google play charts. On July 12 the game reportedly had 21 million active players logged in at once and after just 33 days the game surpassed 100 million downloads on google play and was charted to have. In app purchases brought in over 1 billion dollars by the end of the year and by 2020 that number at reached 6.46 billion.
Needless the say, Pokémon go was a massive success for the brand and put the company comfortable in the ‘early adopter’ section of the social maturity chart.
Now let get to the other side of the hump. One of the biggest and most public mobile failures, Quibi. Maybe we’ve forgotten about Quibi by now but if we do think back, Quibi was quite the talking point during its short lifespan. But for those who don’t remember, Quibi was marketed as the future of streaming as it was the first, mobile, and original content only streaming service. Basically, the only content on Quibi was exclusive to Quibi and the only way to watch Quibi was on your phone. But that’s not all. No episode on Quibi was more than ten minutes long. It was, as the executives put it, a quick bite, or a Quibi. Like other streaming services Quibi offered add supported and ad free versions priced at $4.99 and $7.99 respectively. But, for those who preordered the app, there was a three-month free trial. The marketing for Quibi also went hard with a Superbowl ad and dozens of commercials featuring the celebrity stars of the Quibi shows including Chane the Rapper and Sophie Turner.
Now let’s take a look at Quibi’s launch. The Quibi app dropped on April 6th, 2020, and while it was in the top 11 of most downloaded apps after ten days, it quickly fell out of the top fifty. The projected number of downloads from the company by the end of the first year was 7.4 million, however, by June the projected number was looking closer to 2 million, with only 1 million downloads so far. The end of June also brough the end of the three-month free trial and once the subscription date had passed only 8% of free users had converted into paying customers. That translates to around 80,000 which, if we generously assume all to be paying for ad free services, lands Quibi with a little over $600,000 in subscription revenue. Given the over billion-dollar price tag of Quibi’s launch, this was not a good sign and although management made attempts to raise more money, nothing could stop the sinking ship and after just six months on the market Quibi shut down for good on December 1st, 2020. And even though the Quibi library had 8,500 short form episodes which had cost over a billion dollars to produce, it was sold for less than $100 million to the Roku channel in January 2021.
Even though one of these was a mobile game and one was a streaming service, both were attempting to introduce an innovation into a popular industry. Pokémon Go introduced augmented reality into mainstream mobile gaming and Quibi attempted to introduce short form content into the streaming world. Unfortunately for Quibi they were a little backwards on their stage of social maturity. While they thought they were in the 16% of innovators with short form content streaming, in reality they were in the 16% of laggards in streaming because short form content was the last thing a company would have tried to innovate in the streaming world. Mostly because, it was doomed to fail.






Comments
Post a Comment