Can Groundswell be Controlled?
While companies spend billions a year on research involving customer surveys and focus groups, the true insights into the customers mind come from those who don’t give feedback through these traditional avenues but instead those who contribute to the groundswell. As consumers in the groundswell “are leaving clues about their opinions, positive and negative, on a daily or hourly basis.” (Yi, 123) It is this groundswell which needs to be investigated by corporations to get the best insight on what their brand is according to the public, “Your brand is whatever your costumes say it is. And in the groundswell where they communicate with each other, they decide.” (Yi, 120) A common tool corporations use to do this are companies who are hired to comb through reviews on sites like yelp and trip advisor, however, a very popular trend in the past decade has been using influencers.
In chapter five of Groundswell: Winning in a World Transformed by Social Technologies by Charlotte Yi, one step listed for corporations to listen to the groundswell is, “Find the sources of influence in your market.” (Yi, 141) I think we all thought the same thing as soon as we saw that step, influencers. Over the past decade, influencers have become one of the fastest growing careers in the social media world. These people are content creators who use their platform to promote their sponsor’s products to their audience. This could be a makeup tutorial blogger promoting the new Chanel collection, or a fitness influence promoting the latest energy drink. Additionally, in chapter six the concept of the marketing funnel is introduced. This diagram illustrates the steps from a potential consumer viewing a product to the actual purchase. After every step the number of customers shrink, leaving only a fraction at the end who choose to become a buyer. When applied to influencer culture, there is a difference between corporation loyalty and influencer loyalty. The purpose of an influencer is to connect with their audience on a personal level. The people who are subscribed to influencers, like them as people because they know their personalities better than traditional celebrities. If done right, this creator-audience-relationship can be used to influence the groundswell in small amounts, and create control over a company's image. It doesn’t happen often, but there have been some successful examples.
Our Place has been massively successful in controlling the groundswell for its cookware product, most prominently, the Always Pan. Despite launching right before the pandemic hit in 2020, the current estimated revenue of the company is 57.7 million per year and growing. The secret to the Always Pan’s success? Flooding the influencer market. For a few months the summer of 2020, Our Place gifted dozens of influencers with an Always Pan. This got eyes on their product and that is when they used the key phrases, cult favorite and waitlist. These two phrases were in every single branded video and ad Our Place released promoting the Always Pan. Since it wasn’t just the company, but the influencers also using that description, it tapped into the groundswell thinking and successfully made it their public brand. Once this happened, the work was done for them. The cult favorite mentality implies being a part of something small and special that not too many people know about but will change your life. The term is often used to refer to films which have a small but extremely dedicated following like The Rocky Horror Picture Show. But unlike films, the Always Pan has an entry fee of $150. But that’s when the second brand term comes in, waitlist. Every branded post and official ad would hurry viewers to get their orders in because stock is running out and it could take months if you wait too long. Now this is a common practice used by retailers, creating a limited supply to increase interest and value. The ticking clock on available supplies limits the ability to make rational decisions and increases the chance of someone who is on the fence, taking that step to be a buyer.
But is the marketing all that matters? Of course not. The
product does have to stand on its own in order to retain interest. If we dig
deep enough we can find several unsponsored reviews of the always pan which
talk much more honestly about the shortcomings of the product. But like I said,
we do have to dig for these reviews, and they come from influencers with much
smaller audiences than promoters of the product like The Today Show, Bon Appetit, and The New York Times. I personally would rather spend five dollars on a thrift store pot that looks crappy but does the job than $150 dollars on something pretty which is just passable. But what are your thoughts on the always pan? Is it an example of a corporation successfully controlling the groundswell? Or did they just temporarily create artificial growth which will soon be overtaken by unsponsored, real consumers? Let me know in the comments!



Hi Maeve,
ReplyDeleteOne of the first things that stood out to me was the creator-audience-relationship that you described in your blog post. As I scroll through TikTok it is very common to see brands use UGC creators to showcase their products and piggy back from the creators success or brand image. I find this, from a psychological perspective, to be a very interesting phenomenon. Why do the idea of celebrities or influencers that we create in our head affect so much how we choose to engage online. It really goes to show that what really matters in any marketing strategy is people. How can we create the most positive response that causes people to engage with brands economically. All of these questions rushed into my mind as I read your blog post.
Maeve, your ending questions made me wonder the effectiveness of Self Made's marketing tactic. Especially during the COVID-19 Pandemic, social media usage was higher than normal, people's home aesthetics were growing more important, and home cooking was becoming a necessity, so providing people with their products during that time was genius and definitely triggered artificial growth. However, now that that era is passed, I do think it will be overtaken soon.
ReplyDelete